Right now, many blogging mamas in the Down syndrome community have been writing about the new non-invasive prenatal test for Down syndrome just released two days ago. I too wrote about my opinions regarding terminating a pregnancy simply because the baby has Down syndrome, the day before this test was released. You can find this blog post on our adoption blog
HERE.
I wasn't going to get into the whole debate about this specific blood test, because yes, if this test were offered to me when I was pregnant I would have probably taken it. I would take it to better understand the needs of my child, not because I would choose to terminate.
But then I read
this article posted on my blogging friend
Jenny's blog.
Sadly, I am certain we will see abortion rates rise as more babies with Down syndrome are diagnosed early in pregnancy. At just 10 weeks- before many couples even share the news of their baby on the way.... before tiny flutters are felt, before a heartbeat has been heard on doppler in the doctor's office.... before a mother has really had time to bond with her baby in utero, a tiny life will be discarded because it wasn't deemed
perfect.... a tiny life will be discarded because the parents don't want their child to
suffer.... Let me tell you, if you haven't caught on by reading the other posts on my blog- Evan IS absolutely perfect the way he is, and he does NOT
suffer from having Down syndrome!! Ask any adult with Down syndrome and they will tell you the same.
Art Caplan, director at the center for bioethics at the University of Pennsylvania, shared his views and I absolutely agree with him. Taken from the article linked above on Bloomberg Businessweek:
For many people this test makes it morally, emotionally and psychologically easier to have an abortion,” Caplan said in an interview.... Caplan said future prenatal tests may be able to indicate if the fetus had biomarkers for Alzheimer’s disease, or breast cancer, or other diseases. Those tests will raise questions about what issues will trigger potential parents to choose an abortion. A survey published last month in the American Journal of Medical Genetics showed that only 4 percent of parents with Down Syndrome children regretted having them.
Ok, now I'm having real issues with these possible future prenatal tests. It seems these people are looking for a crystal ball to predict the future, and termination would be the ONLY reason to perform these tests. I can definitely understand the desire to know if your child has Down syndrome prenatally so you can be better prepared for the birth and upbringing. The baby will benefit from therapies very early on, and parents can research other issues and concerns. The health of the baby can be better monitored in case there are any heart or other defects that can occur more often in children with DS. But yes, a big reason this test was developed to diagnose DS much earlier in pregnancy was to give parents more opportunity to terminate. So incredibly sad.
And seriously- what reason would you have to find out if your unborn child has a biomarker for breast cancer other than to terminate?? How many of
us could have this biomarker and not know it? Of course they can't determine at what age the child/adult will be diagnosed with breast cancer if at all. How about asking all those affected with breast cancer- do you regret being born at all since you are now faced with breast cancer? What if it is your mother? Your best friend? Most of us in society know at least one person who has had breast cancer. Would the world be a better place if they weren't born? Would their upbringing as a child be a hindrance or burden to their parents? Of course not. And I'm sure there have been plenty of people who have died from other causes before any knowledge of a breast cancer marker being present.
What if a new test came out to predict your child's post-secondary education? How about a test to predict if they will experience extreme heartache in their life? A test to predict if they will ever suffer a severe injury in the future? Where will the line be drawn??
Yes, I have gotten way off the topic of Down syndrome, but this new test has opened a huge can of worms. Without proper education on the accuracy of the tests as well as what life is REALLY like on the other side of receiving a diagnosis, I truly fear for the future and what society deems as acceptable.